Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer
Elvie Curve vs Haakaa- Momtherly

Elvie Curve vs Haakaa: Which One Should I Buy?

Every Mom deserves anything that will make their life easier, this article on Elvie curve vs Haakaa is to make motherhood easier for you.

 Breastfeeding is a major part of the motherhood journey. Elvie Curve and Haakaa are amazing products and they make life easier for moms but we can not buy the two, right? 

So which one should I buy?

Elvie Curve vs Haakaa: Get to know them First 

You may not realize it if you’re an expecting parent, but when you’re breastfeeding your kid on one breast, the other breast leaks and this is where the Elvie Curve and Haakaa come in handy. 

They are silicone manual pumps that gather milk during the letdown when you’re nursing your baby on the opposite breast using natural suction.

Although, a nursing pad can be inserted into your bra to absorb all of the milk. However, many mothers consider this a waste of their precious fluid! You may make a nice freezer stash with these two, which will come in handy when you return to work and the baby is with someone else like a babysitter, who will be able to feed the baby with your breastmilk.

If you ask me, I will say they are the banks for liquid gold – Breastmilk! 

They are silicone manual pumps that use natural suction to collect milk during the letdown while you’re nursing your baby on the opposite breast.

Asides from being a bank, the Elvie Curve or Haakaa helps to assist in reducing engorgement by speeding up the process of breastfeeding. They may also aid in the expansion of your milk supply, but be cautious because this could lead to having more than enough. 

Elvie Curve vs. Haakaa: Similarities between them 

Elvie Curve and Haakaa have similarities between them that make them have a tie. I will be highlighting these features. 

  1. While the pumps’ shapes are vastly different, they are both exceedingly simple to transfer the milk from pump to storage bag (or bottle) once you’ve finished pumping.
  2. They both have a flat bottom that makes them easy to set on a table. 
  3. Both the Haakaa and the Elvie Curve can hold 4 ounces of milk(some moms say Haakaa is one ounce less). 
  4. Elvie Curve and Haakaa are both made of soft, food-grade silicone that can be washed in the dishwasher. This makes the pumps machine washable. 
  5. You will need to use two hands to get the pumps in place and properly attached, and one hand to apply extra suction.

Now, after looking at the similarities between these pumps. Let us look at each of these pumps. 

Elvie Curve Review

Elvie Curve vs Haakaa Manual Wearable Breast PumpThe Elvie Curve is a wearable hands-free silicone breast pump. It is quiet, wearable, wireless, and tubeless. The Elvie allows you to efficiently engage in other activities while expressing milk. 

Pros 

  1. The breast pump allows you to wear it while wearing a bra (no undressing required! )
  2. It is very handy and saves time.
  3. It’s a hands-free device that allows you to multi-task.
  4.  It fits comfortably and firmly in your bra (again, due to the form). 
  5. Strong Suction 
  6. The Elvie curve comes with a valve that allows you to reduce suction or remove it completely. 

Cons

  1. The ounces on the silicone container are written in tiny letters which makes it difficult to read. 
  2. It is difficult to see the amount of milk you have while breastfeeding because of the opaque cover of the silicone container. 
  3. It is pricier than the Haakaa. 

Price: $49.98 – Shop The Elvie Curve on Amazon

How to Use Elvie Curve

 

Haakaa Review

Haakaa Breast Pump with suction base

Haakaa is a manual silicone breast pump that collects milk through suction. It’s in the shape of a glass, with a funnel on top. 

Pros

  • You can easily know the amount of milk you have pumped which makes you to know when you need to apply additional suction at any time when pumping.
  • After pumping, the side of the Haakaa is easy to read so you can easily and precisely label your storage bag with the amount of milk collected. 
  • It is cheaper than the Elvie Curve. 

Cons

  1. Moms have complained that it comes loose and falls off which makes it not exactly hands-free. 
  2. Growing babies are known to kick the reservoir, causing it to spill.

Price: $12.94 – Shop The Haakaa Pump on Amazon

How to use Haakaa Breast Pump 

 

Elvie Curve vs Haakaa Ladybug

Haakaa has a different version called Ladybug

.Unlike the Elvie Curve, the  Haakaa Ladybug has just one piece made of soft silicone. This makes it easy to squeeze and bend in all directions. 

Haakaa Ladybug also has a large breast opening, and because it is so soft, it easily loses suction and fails to stay on the breast (leading to milk spilling on you). Haakaa ladybug is also cheaper than the Elvie curve. \

Elvie Curve vs Haakaa — which one is better?

I think both the Elvie Curve and the Haakaa are fantastic breast pumps that you would be satisfied with. However, if you want a hands-free discreet, and effective breast pump then Elvie Curve is a better choice for you but if it is beyond your budget then Haakaa is not a bad option too. 

Frequently Asked Questions

Can You Use Elvie Curve As A  Breast Pump?

There is no substitute for double electric pumps (such as Elvie Pump, Medela, Willow, etc.). This is especially true if you plan to exclusively pump. However, you can express additional milk with the manual pump while you are breastfeeding (or using an electric pump) on the other breast.

Can You Wear Elvie Curve All Day?

Wearing Elvie Curve all day is not recommended. Wear your Elvie Curve bra on one side, while feeding your infant on the other side, while pumping on the opposite breast, or when you feel your breasts are engorged and need relief from the discomfort. As soon as you’ve finished expressing milk, remove Elvie Curve and transfer milk into an additional container or bag. (You should consider getting a comfortable nursing bra too.) 

Can You Pump With Haakaa?

Just like the Elvie Curve, Haakaa is not a substitute for electric breast pumps, but it’s a great way to collect extra milk when you’re breastfeeding or pumping and your other breast is leaking. Both of them are designed only for letdown. 

Why Is Haakaa Not Recommended?

Haakaa or other manual silicone pumps (like Elvie Curve) are not recommended by some moms due to the risk of oversupply, which can prove difficult to manage. Check out this comprehensive review on Haakaa Pumps. 

 

 

Writer at | + posts
Show CommentsClose Comments

Leave a comment